Cedar Vs Redwood Fence – Which One Is The Best Option?

The Cedar vs Redwood fence has always been an engagement when it comes to the best kind of fence. We all want the best pieces for our house, especially the fence which protects the house and catches the others’ eye first. 

There is an assortment of materials offering the natural aesthetic vibe for this part of your house. However, choosing wood as the fence material is a worth-considering choice. 

We will dig into more cedar and redwood characteristics in this article to figure out which one is your material of choice. 

An Overview About Cedar And Redwood

Let’s have a general look at cedar and redwood:

Cedar

Cedar originates from Cedar trees which thrive intensely in the Himalayas and some areas in the Mediterranean, and they also appear in mild regions. Cedar has a unique smell that no other woods can match.

Redwood

Nowadays, people can only find Redwood trees on the shoreline from middle California to southern Oregon. Redwood does not have a signature smell like cedar. 

Cedar Vs Redwood Fence – How Do They Differ From Each Other?

To select the appropriate fence, we go to the details of the differences in all sides of cedar and redwood:

Appearance

Color

Color is a noticeable distinction for all lumber consumers. Cedar and redwood have their unique color that we can easily distinguish. 

The cedar comes with a natural tone. Cedar’s color varies from pastel pink to a yellowish tone, then to almost whiteness. If you are up to color and decorate your fence, this wood is ideal because of its brighter natural hue and less cost.

Cedar Vs Redwood Fence

Meanwhile, as the name suggests, redwood stands out for a remarkable brown-reddish shade. If your favorite color is red, you will be amazed at natural redwood’s color without painting or staining. 

Cedar Vs Redwood Fence

When not preserved, the color will fade to a silver-gray tone with time. Some people enjoy this transition because it gives their fence a more natural appearance. However, others would disapprove, preferring to keep the original look by maintaining them annually. 

Grains

Cedar grains are dense and homogeneous and distribute uniformly and tight along with the wood sheet. In contrast, the grain of redwood is more widely spaced, yet it is quite even. Because redwood matures quicker than cedar, its grain is often broader.

Number Of Knots

Another primary difference between cedar and redwood is the number of knots in the wood. Redwood has fewer knots compared with cedar since it is generally collected from giant older trees. 

Redwood is much more easily obtainable in various grades, some of which do not have any knots. There is no doubt that redwood seems to have a minor advantage over cedar in terms of total cleanliness.

Environment Protection

Fascinatingly, both of the two fence materials are environmentally friendly. Compared to their artificial counterparts, cedar and redwood fences are more eco-sustainable because they are made entirely of natural ingredients. 

Durability

Durability is the key factor in choosing a wood fence. Cedar and redwood fences all have considerable durability. If you take a closer look, there is a little dissimilarity between them. 

Hardness

We would like to introduce “Janka” – a scale to test wood hardness. As per it, redwood has a rate of around 450lbs, while cedar comes with only 350lbs. That means redwood is mostly up to 23% harder than cedar.

Decay And Rot Resistance

There are two parts in cedar and redwood which are heartwood and sapwood. In heartwood pieces, they create various extractives to help them be resistant to decay and rot. The sapwood fails for it, but it doesn’t matter because of its small amount.

The Dark Part Inside Is Heartwood

Cedar trees’ heartwood contains a range from 10% to 20% extractives. Redwood trees have a higher percentage of extractives, over 20%, than cedar. As you can see, redwood is stronger and more durable against harsh elements than cedar. 

Maintenance

You can find it simple to clean both cedar and redwood fences with water and soap. To recover their color, you can spray the typical treatment containing oxalic acid, which is easy to buy in specialized stores. 

Cedar and redwood automatically produce the substances (cedar with thujic acid and redwood with tannin) that kill bugs. These chemicals offer a helping hand in preventing insect resistance. It’s extremely beneficial for your outdoor fence. 

The stains with a semi-transparent oil or linseed oil basement would be the best option for applying them to your fence again. It should be at least two years and up to 4 years for repainting; 3 years for restaining. 

Both need upkeep; if not, it leads to their low longevity. These would persist for up to 16 years if left careless, but you can see major rot or deterioration if you continue to ignore them.

Wood Decay

Availability

Cedar trees provide a yield high enough to serve the needs of most consumers around the world. Cedar is more likely to be available in your area. You can pick from a variety of cedar types, including Eastern Red, Eastern White, and Western Red cedar.

In contrast, because of their specific habitat, the availability of redwood is quite limited. Before deciding to purchase a redwood fence, it is advisable to check whether there is any available near you. 

Price 

Price is one of the elements that you cannot miss in choosing a fence. Typically, cedar comes at a more reasonable price than redwood. With the same lumber size, cedar is around 15% cheaper overall than redwood. 

Despite redwood’s significant strength and durability, many fence builders choose cedar because it achieves quite good quality in a more affordable price range.   

Conclusion

Cedar vs Redwood fence – the never-ending combat since each of them has its distinct characteristics. In summary, they are excellent options that you should write in your list. 

The last piece of advice that we want to give you is to look back at your preferences for your fence, your financial ability, and the convenience of buying and maintaining. Hope you’ll make up your mind soon! 

Reference Source: Building a Redwood Deck and a Redwood and Cedar Fence

Leave a Comment